| Name/Year | College/University | Division | High School | |
| John Barnes ’14 | Oswego | III | Greenwich | |
| Kyle McAlonie ’14 | HVCC | JC | Shenendehowa | |
| Kyle Chambers ’15 | St. John Fisher | III | Queensbury | |
| Sean Dempsey’15 | Catholic U. | III | Albany Academy | |
| Justin Germain ’15 | Onondaga CC | JC | LaSalle | |
| Matt Hamel ’15 | Siena | I | CBA | |
| Josh Hayner ’15 | Messiah | III | Shenendehowa | |
| Jake Petralia ’15 | FMCC | JC | Schuylerville | |
| Brad Pearson ’15 | Clarkson | III | Shenendehowa | |
| Jake Walter ’15 | Canisius | I | Columbia | |
| Bryan Warzek ’15 | U. New Orleans | I | Shenendehowa | Dodgers 6th Round |
| Ben Anderson ’16 | Binghamton | I | Shenendehowa | Rangers 13th Round |
| Shane Barringer ‘16 | Siena | I | Saratoga | |
| Joe Duncan ‘16 | Western Connecticut | III | Hoosick Valley | |
| Tanner Dunkel ‘16 | Wells | III | Schuylerville | |
| Ryan Flansburg ‘16 | Herkimer CC | JC | Queensbury | |
| Brendan Frank ‘16 | St. Lawerence | III | Saratoga | |
| Nick Jacques ‘16 | LeMoyne | II | Shenendehowa | |
| Mike Maddalone ‘16 | Ithaca | III | LaSalle | |
| Nik Malachowski ‘16 | Brockport | III | Shenendehowa | |
| Brett Rodriguez ‘16 | Wofford | I | Queensbury | |
| Justin Troelstra ’16 | Oswego | III | Queensbury | |
| Dan Yankowski ‘16 | Albany | I | Ichabod Crane | |
| Garrett Bailey ‘17 | Cornell | I | Fort Ann | |
| Peter Close ‘17 | RPI | III | CBA | |
| Jake Defayette ‘17 | RPI | III | Schalmont | |
| Kurt Forsell ’17 | St. John Fisher | III | Shenendehowa | |
| Anthony Germinerio ’17 | Albany | I | Averill Park | |
| Jeremy Johnson ‘17 | St. Joseph's | NAIA | Fort Ann | |
| Tyler Mattison ‘17 | Bryant | I | Fort Ann | |
| Matt Toy ’17 | Union | III | Niskayuna | |
| Michael Spulnick ’17 | Brockport | III | Shenendehowa | |
| Carson Dunkel ’18 | Siena | I | Schuylerville | |
| Noah Edwards ’18 | SUNY Sullivan | JC | Queensbury | |
| Connor Houle’18 | Franklin Pierce | II | Waterford | |
| Jack Kelleher ’18 | St. John Fisher | III | Lake George | |
| Cole Paquin ’18 | RPI | III | Shenendehowa | |
| Ben Shpur ’18 | Clarkson | III | Queensbury | |
| Danny St. Clare ‘18 | Albany | I | Whitehall | |
| Evan St. Claire ‘18 | Siena | I | Whitehall | |
| David Yankowski ’18 | Canisius | I | Ichabod Crane | |
| Joe Novenche ’18 | Canisius | I | Shenendehowa | |
| Jaelin Robin ‘18 | Hamilton | III | Shaker | |
| Nate Chudy ’19 | Holy Cross | I | Saratoga | |
| Ben Lavery ’19 | St. John Fisher | III | Shenendehowa | |
| Riley Orr ’19 | Castleton | III | Lake George | |
| Brendan Scott ’19 | Brockport | III | Queensbury | |
| Connor Bovair ’20 | Siena | I | S. Glens Falls | |
| Jake Reinisch ’20 | Wake Forest | I | Shenendehowa |
barnstormers alumni